SGB vs Gold ETF vs Physical Gold: Tax & Returns Compared

Two gold investments can track the same price yet leave you with very different amounts after tax and costs. This guide zooms in on the after-tax picture for Sovereign Gold Bonds, gold ETFs and physical gold so you keep more of your gains.
The tax headline
SGBs are the most tax-efficient: capital gains on redemption at maturity are tax-free for individuals. Gold ETFs and physical gold are taxed as capital gains based on holding period, so a chunk of long-term gains goes to tax.
Extra income
Only SGBs pay interest — 2.5% a year on the initial investment. That income is taxable at your slab, but it compounds your total return versus ETFs and physical gold, which pay nothing.
Costs that eat returns
Physical jewellery loses 8–25% to making charges plus 3% GST. ETFs charge a small annual expense ratio. SGBs have essentially no holding cost. Lower costs mean higher net returns over time.
Liquidity trade-off
The catch with SGBs is liquidity: best returns require holding to maturity. ETFs let you exit any market day. If flexibility matters more than the last bit of after-tax return, ETFs may suit you better.
Bottom line
For maximum after-tax return on a long horizon, SGBs usually win. For flexibility, ETFs. Physical gold rarely wins on returns and is best reserved for adornment or gifting.
- Maximise after-tax return, long horizon → SGB
- Need liquidity → Gold ETF
- Want to wear/gift → physical gold